Shop old penny candy

Sponsored
$49.99
1960'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$49.99
1960'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 1960S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 60S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
490
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 1960S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 60S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
490
$49.99
1980'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$49.99
1980'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1950S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 50S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
589
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1950S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 50S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
589
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1940S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 40S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
486
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1940S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 40S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
486
$49.99
1950'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$49.99
1950'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns
$159.98
$209.99
3000 Pc Bulk Value Candy Assortment
Oriental Trading Company
90
23% off
$159.98
$209.99
3000 Pc Bulk Value Candy Assortment
Oriental Trading Company
90
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1970S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 70S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
393
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co 1970S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 70S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
393
$22.98
$24.99
206 Pc Bulk Kid's Combo Assorted Candy
Oriental Trading Company
85
$22.98
$24.99
206 Pc Bulk Kid's Combo Assorted Candy
Oriental Trading Company
85
$32.95
Deluxe Size Retro Candy Box
Etsy
646
Free shipping
$32.95
Deluxe Size Retro Candy Box
Etsy
646
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 1930S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 30S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
549
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 1930S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 30S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
549
$49.99
1970'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$49.99
1970'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns
$79.98
$84.99
1000 Pc Bulk Small Candy Assortment
Oriental Trading Company
3
$79.98
$84.99
1000 Pc Bulk Small Candy Assortment
Oriental Trading Company
3
$42.95
Can Of Nostalgic Candy 70 Pieces!
Blair Candy Company
$42.95
Can Of Nostalgic Candy 70 Pieces!
Blair Candy Company
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 2000S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - Y2K Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
Free shipping
$44.99
Vintage Candy Co. 2000S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - Y2K Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
Etsy
Free shipping
$3.59
Nostalgic 1847 Original NECCO Candy Wafers 24Ct Display Box
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$3.59
Nostalgic 1847 Original NECCO Candy Wafers 24Ct Display Box
Faire
60-day returns
$49.99
1990'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns (most items)
$49.99
1990'S Retro Candy Gift
Faire
60-day returns
$2.30
Candy Buttons Personal Size
Blair Candy Company
$2.30
Candy Buttons Personal Size
Blair Candy Company
$39.99
Vintage Candy CO. Happy Birthday FUN Candy Care Package - Modern And Retro Candies Assortment Variety - GAG Gift Basket - Perfect For Adults, College
Walmart
4
$39.99
Vintage Candy CO. Happy Birthday FUN Candy Care Package - Modern And Retro Candies Assortment Variety - GAG Gift Basket - Perfect For Adults, College
Walmart
4
$2.05
Claey's Wild Cherry Old Fashion Hard Candies 6Oz Bag
Blair Candy Company
6K+
$2.05
Claey's Wild Cherry Old Fashion Hard Candies 6Oz Bag
Blair Candy Company
6K+
$13.99
Nostalgic Candy Fun Pack, Old Fashioned Penny Candy, Retro Candy Perfect For Any Celebration, Party Themed, Assorted Old School Candies.
Etsy
1K+
$13.99
Nostalgic Candy Fun Pack, Old Fashioned Penny Candy, Retro Candy Perfect For Any Celebration, Party Themed, Assorted Old School Candies.
Etsy
1K+
$8.95
Melody Pops Suckers Whistle Pops Nostalgic Candy Retro Candy Pack Of Six (6) Suckers
Etsy
1K+
$8.95
Melody Pops Suckers Whistle Pops Nostalgic Candy Retro Candy Pack Of Six (6) Suckers
Etsy
1K+
$15.99
Arcor Strawberry Bon Bons Candy 3 Lb Bag, Strawberry Flavor, Individually Wrapped Bulk Candy, Pink Color, Old-Fashioned, Nostalgic Candy.
Etsy
1K+
$15.99
Arcor Strawberry Bon Bons Candy 3 Lb Bag, Strawberry Flavor, Individually Wrapped Bulk Candy, Pink Color, Old-Fashioned, Nostalgic Candy.
Etsy
1K+
$19.95
Old-Fashioned Filled Peanut Candy - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$19.95
Old-Fashioned Filled Peanut Candy - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$39.99
Vintage Candy CO. 13th Birthday Retro Candy Gift Basket - 2010 Party Assortment Candy Variety - Fun Care Package Gift Basket - Thirteen Birthday - Per
Walmart
$39.99
Vintage Candy CO. 13th Birthday Retro Candy Gift Basket - 2010 Party Assortment Candy Variety - Fun Care Package Gift Basket - Thirteen Birthday - Per
Walmart
$29.95
Dark Chocolate Cream Drops, 1 Pound Box - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$29.95
Dark Chocolate Cream Drops, 1 Pound Box - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$713.84
70'S Nostalgia Box (24 Packs)
Imprint Now
60-day returns (most items)
$713.84
70'S Nostalgia Box (24 Packs)
Imprint Now
60-day returns
$19.90
Classic Candy Fruit Slices - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$19.90
Classic Candy Fruit Slices - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$11.99
$14.99
Old-Fashioned Candy
Swiss Colony
More than 870 people from Bing viewed this product in the last 90 days
20% off
$11.99
$14.99
Old-Fashioned Candy
Swiss Colony
870+ viewed
$35.97
Penny Candy 2.5 Lbs Cinnamon Fireballs Candy
Walmart
Free shipping
$35.97
Penny Candy 2.5 Lbs Cinnamon Fireballs Candy
Walmart
Free shipping
$25.33
Penny Candy Strawberry Filled Candies, 2.50 Lb - PEC014 | On Time Supplies
On Time Supplies
$25.33
Penny Candy Strawberry Filled Candies, 2.50 Lb - PEC014 | On Time Supplies
On Time Supplies
$21.39
$26.31
Penny Candy Zotz
Shoplet.com
18% off
$21.39
$26.31
Penny Candy Zotz
Shoplet.com
$19.99
Traditional Candy
Swiss Colony
$19.99
Traditional Candy
Swiss Colony
$26.03
Penny Candy M&M's Orignal, Chocolate, 2 Lb, 1 Bag (PEC011) 1 Bag
GoodEarth Products
$26.03
Penny Candy M&M's Orignal, Chocolate, 2 Lb, 1 Bag (PEC011) 1 Bag
GoodEarth Products
$30.80
$37.88
Penny Candy M&M's Orignal
Shoplet.com
18% off
$30.80
$37.88
Penny Candy M&M's Orignal
Shoplet.com
$19.24
Penny Candy Smarties, 2.50 Lb, 1 Bag (PEC006) 1 Bag
GoodEarth Products
$19.24
Penny Candy Smarties, 2.50 Lb, 1 Bag (PEC006) 1 Bag
GoodEarth Products
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop old penny candy

    Sponsored
    $49.99
    1960'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $49.99
    1960'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 1960S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 60S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    490
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 1960S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 60S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    490
    $49.99
    1980'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $49.99
    1980'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1950S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 50S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    589
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1950S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 50S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    589
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1940S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 40S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    486
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1940S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 40S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    486
    $49.99
    1950'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $49.99
    1950'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $159.98
    $209.99
    3000 Pc Bulk Value Candy Assortment
    Oriental Trading Company
    90
    23% off
    $159.98
    $209.99
    3000 Pc Bulk Value Candy Assortment
    Oriental Trading Company
    90
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1970S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 70S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    393
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co 1970S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 70S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    393
    $22.98
    $24.99
    206 Pc Bulk Kid's Combo Assorted Candy
    Oriental Trading Company
    85
    $22.98
    $24.99
    206 Pc Bulk Kid's Combo Assorted Candy
    Oriental Trading Company
    85
    $32.95
    Deluxe Size Retro Candy Box
    Etsy
    646
    Free shipping
    $32.95
    Deluxe Size Retro Candy Box
    Etsy
    646
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 1930S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 30S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    549
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 1930S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - 30S Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    549
    $49.99
    1970'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $49.99
    1970'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $79.98
    $84.99
    1000 Pc Bulk Small Candy Assortment
    Oriental Trading Company
    3
    $79.98
    $84.99
    1000 Pc Bulk Small Candy Assortment
    Oriental Trading Company
    3
    $42.95
    Can Of Nostalgic Candy 70 Pieces!
    Blair Candy Company
    $42.95
    Can Of Nostalgic Candy 70 Pieces!
    Blair Candy Company
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 2000S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - Y2K Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $44.99
    Vintage Candy Co. 2000S Retro Decade Candy Gift Assortment - Y2K Candies Mix - Best Candies Gift Idea For Woman Man Girl Boy College Student
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $3.59
    Nostalgic 1847 Original NECCO Candy Wafers 24Ct Display Box
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $3.59
    Nostalgic 1847 Original NECCO Candy Wafers 24Ct Display Box
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $49.99
    1990'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns (most items)
    $49.99
    1990'S Retro Candy Gift
    Faire
    60-day returns
    $2.30
    Candy Buttons Personal Size
    Blair Candy Company
    $2.30
    Candy Buttons Personal Size
    Blair Candy Company