After finding an Amish recipe for oatmeal pie, we had to try it ... In a large bowl, combine eggs, brown sugar, corn syrup and granulated sugar. Stir in vanilla and salt. Whisk in butter.

When The Amish: Shunned premiered ... Pour the sticky bun syrup into three nine-inch pie pans. Add pecans or walnuts if desired. Mix together the white sugar and cinnamon and set it aside.

Amish caramel toast is a convenient snack made of bread, butter, brown sugar, and heavy cream ... try making your own Dutch apple pie or soggy-bottomed Shoofly pie, which has a simple molasses ...