Our favorite: Kirkland Signature Pecan Pie Weighing in at four pounds and six ounces, this decadent pie was the most expensive of the three, at $16.99, but we found it to be worth every penny.

Costco's iconic — and positively ginormous — pecan pie has officially returned to the bakery section. Let the countdown to Turkey Day commence: T-14 days until Thanksgiving !

While Costco suggests a serving size of 12 slices, we found that these colossal pies can be cut into squares to yield at least 16 servings. That’s a whole lotta pie!

In 2023, Costco notched sales of 2.9 million pumpkin pies and 1.3 million apple and pecan pies in the U.S. during the Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday before Thanksgiving.

Each Costco pie serves at least 12. 3. Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie. ... “I’m normally wary of pecan pie since it’s like eating pecan-topped sugar goo.